Skip to content

Painting Monona's mid-century houses, inside and on the lake side

Madison wraps almost all the way around Monona, a city built mostly in the 1950s and 1960s. What houses from those years need from paint, indoors and by the water.

Sunset over Lake Monona from a wooden pier at Stone Bridge Park in Monona, Wisconsin.
Photo: Alexsuchy, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Monona is a small lake city that Madison almost completely surrounds, and its houses are older than those of any other town we serve: the median one was built in 1963, and about 68% went up before 1980.

So this is a page about mid-century houses. Their solid trim and simple kitchens take paint well, but six decades of repaints and remodels sit on top of the original finishes, and homes near the shore add a deck and doors that face open water. Here's what to expect in the rooms, in the kitchen and on the lake side.

What we do in Monona

  • Refinishing mid-century kitchen cabinets in Monona

    Built around the kitchens of the city's postwar boom: flat slab doors that show every brush mark, soffits over the uppers, rooms updated one piece at a time, period pulls, and whether refinishing still makes sense when a bigger remodel might come in a few years.

  • Painting paneled dens, textured ceilings and flush doors in Monona

    For dens and rec rooms from the 1950s and 1960s. It covers solid boards versus sheet paneling and the primer each needs, the EPA's caution about textured ceilings that haven't been tested, flush doors with thin veneer faces, and colors from the period that suit a paneled wall.

  • Monona decks, garage doors and front doors after a lake winter

    What a long lake winter leaves on a ranch or split level: wood garage doors worn along the bottom edge, trim paint that cracks every spring, decks under snow, shovels and ice melt, and front door colors that give a long, low facade a focal point.

Monona homes at a glance

Housing in the city of Monona, U.S. Census Bureau estimates for 2020 to 2024 (source)
Homes counted4,341
Median year built1963
Built before 198068%
Built 1980 to 199911%
Built 2000 or later21%
Owner occupied54%
Single-family detached56%

Inside a house from the boom years

Start with the trim and doors. Plenty of mid-century houses kept their original casings and doors, and under today's color there's often oil-based paint from the first owners. New water-based paint holds on that only after cleaning, scuff sanding and a bonding primer, and on a repaint that prep is most of the work.

The rooms carry other markers of the era: paneling in a den or basement, texture on a ceiling, slim casings and flat doors. Paneling paints well with a stain-blocking primer. A textured ceiling is another matter, because the EPA lists textured coatings among the places asbestos can turn up and says you usually can't tell by looking, so have an untested one tested before anyone paints or scrapes it. The Monona interior page goes into both.

Kitchens from the boom tend to be compact, with slab doors and a soffit above the uppers, and most have been updated at least once. Refinishing keeps that layout and gives every door one finish, which is why refinishing Monona's mid-century kitchens spends its time on slab doors and mixed remodels.

At the five to ten years a coat on an interior wall usually lasts, by the numbers in our post on how long paint lasts, a room from 1963 may have been painted half a dozen times. If the dining room is first on your list, our guide to dining room paint colors helps with a room used mostly in the evening, and if a later owner added crown molding, painting crown molding covers the order and the ladder work.

The side of the house that faces the water

Lake Monona has about 13 miles of shoreline, and Madison holds three sides of it; Monona has the southeast. On a lakefront lot, the side facing the water is often the busiest in summer, with the deck, the door out to it and the steps down the yard, and it's usually the most exposed side too.

The Forest Products Laboratory, the federal wood research lab in Madison, says the parts of a house fully exposed to sun and rain are the first to deteriorate. Deck boards lie flat, where water sits and sunlight hits squarely, and the lab's deck guidance favors penetrating stains over paint or solid-color stain, with pigment shielding the wood from the sun.

The door that opens onto the deck takes the same weather plus hands, boots and wet towels, so its edges and sill tend to wear first. Then comes winter: the lake is typically frozen for about 107 days, and every freeze and thaw works water into cracks in old paint. We take care of those decks, doors and trim; whole-house siding isn't something we paint.

Wet boards can't take stain, so work on the water side waits for a dry stretch, and a deck under trees may need longer to dry than one in full sun. The Monona deck and door page covers winter wear, ice melt and garage doors, and our deck staining and exterior page lists everything we do outside.

Farmland and summer homes until 1938

Before Monona incorporated as a village on August 29, 1938, the area was mostly farmland and summer homes. The boom came next: during the 1950s the population more than tripled, from 2,544 to 8,178. The village opened a community center and swimming pool in 1963, the same year as its median home in today's Census estimates, and became a city in 1969.

The land holds much older history as well. The Tompkins-Brindler Mound Group in Woodland Park is a reminder that people lived along this shore long before the subdivisions.

Three square miles, mostly built by 1980

Monona covers about 3.35 square miles, nearly all of it land, with Madison on almost every side and the lake along the rest. Most of its building was done early, and the Census shows it: only about 21% of its homes have been built since 2000, and just 11% date from 1980 to 1999.

Not every mid-century home here sits on its own lot. A little over half of Monona's homes are detached single-family houses, and about 54% are lived in by their owners, so apartments, condos and rented homes make up a real share of the city. The prep for a 1960s room is the same whoever holds the deed.

Common questions

Is Monona part of Madison?

No. Monona is a separate city, incorporated as a village in 1938 and as a city in 1969. Madison surrounds it on nearly every side, so the border is easy to cross without noticing, but Monona has its own city government and its own Census figures.

Do you work on houses right on the lake?

Yes. A lakefront house gets the same work as any other, inside and out. The difference is exposure: the water side tends to take more sun, wind and winter than the street side, so its deck and doors usually need attention sooner and the work waits for a dry spell.

What do mid-century houses usually need first: the kitchen, the rooms or the outside?

Whatever is failing, then whatever bothers you most. Peeling exterior paint or a gray, thirsty deck should go first, since the weather keeps working on them. After that it's your call: the kitchen changes the look of the house the most, while rooms can be done one or two at a time.

What should I have ready before George visits?

The year the house was built, a list of the rooms or pieces you want done, and a rough count of cabinet doors and drawers if the kitchen is included. Results from any ceiling texture test help, and so do a few photos of the deck and lake-side doors at their worst. When that's together, send us a request.

What if my house was built before 1978?

Then mention the build year on the phone, because the EPA says homes built before 1978 are more likely to contain lead-based paint. The agency notes that paint in good shape usually isn't the hazard; chips, peeling and the dust from sanding or scraping are. Its Renovation, Repair and Painting program sets federal rules for how paid crews handle work that disturbs that paint, which matters in a city where about 68% of homes predate 1980.

Other towns we serve

Helpful guides

Sources

  1. American Community Survey 2020-2024 5-year estimates, U.S. Census Bureau, via Census Reporter
  2. Monona, Wisconsin, Wikipedia
  3. Lake Monona, Wikipedia
  4. Finishing of Wood (Wood Handbook, chapter 15), USDA Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory
  5. Finishes for Wood Decks, USDA Forest Service, Forest Products Laboratory
  6. Protect Your Family from Exposures to Asbestos, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
  7. Reduce the Risk of Lead Exposure at Home, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
  8. Lead Renovation, Repair and Painting Program, U.S. Environmental Protection Agency

Get a free estimate in Monona

Send a few details. George will call to talk it through, visit if he needs to see the space, and send a free written quote.

Fully insured. George on every job. Thumbtack Top Pro 2023 to 2025.